German Education and Research Minister Bettina Stark-Watzinger has again warned that China may be exerting undue influence on German universities via the Confucius Institutes. "Clear limits" must be set for "direct influence," Stark-Watzinger said in an interview with the German newspaper Handelsblatt in June.
In the weeks since those comments, her ministry confirmed to DW that this had triggered no Chinese reaction.
Confucius, who lived from 551-479 B.C., is arguably China's most important philosopher. About 20 years ago, Beijing set up the Confucius Institute as an official educational organization and it began to establish such entities worldwide in 2004. According to Chinese official figures, their number has grown to about 500 in more than 90 countries.
The stated mission of the institutes is to promote the Chinese language and culture - a similar goal to organizations from other countries, including Germany's Goethe Institute. At the same time, the Confucius Institutes play a significant role in the helping China to open up, both culturally and politically. Most of the time, but not always, Confucius Institutes are established in partnership with local higher education institutions and universities.
Confucius Institutes face accusations of propaganda
As long as these institutes have existed, there have been allegations they serve as a propaganda tool for the authoritarian leadership in Beijing. In short: China gives money for research or scientific projects and cultural initiatives, thereby gaining influence and control. Critics have warned that academic freedom is at stake.
The Confucius Institutes use university facilities, take on or contribute to Chinese language learning opportunities and organize lectures, cultural experiences and student trips. The costs for each institute are shared between China via its foreign cultural outreach organization and the local Institute or university, with support from German state governments.
An example of pressure exerted by Beijing was widely reported in German media in 2021 when the Confucius Institute at the University Duisburg-Essen organized a reading of a new biography of Chinese President Xi Jinping, which included the topic of the cult of personality surrounding
Xi. But after an intervention from Beijing, the institute canceled the presentation.
Institutes 'threaten to undermine academic freedom'
According to the German government, there are 19 Confucius Institutes throughout Germany, mostly based at universities.
In its annual reports, the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, Germany's domestic intelligence agency, has long classified the institutes as an instrument of political influence. "In the field of education and research, China's activities and forms of cooperation threaten to undermine academic freedom," its current report reads.
In response to growing concern, some joint initiatives have been discontinued.
In June 2022, Education and Research Minister Minister Stark-Watzinger - a member of the neoliberal Free Democrats (FDP) - already urged the scholarly community to critically assess their cooperation arrangements with the Confucius Institutes. "We should clearly distance ourselves," she said back then, doubling down a year later.
She has now received support from Interior Minister Nancy Faeser, of Chancellor Olaf Scholz's center-left Social Democrats (SPD), who has said she regards the collaborations as "extremely critically from a security point of view." This drew support from Norbert Röttgen, foreign policy spokesperson for the opposition center-right Christian Democratic Union (CDU), who wrote on Twitter "I cannot help but support the federal government on this."
A look back at recent German-Chinese relations
Appeals from federal politicians are one thing, but decisions are another. In Germany, education policy is primarily the responsibility of each of the 16 federal states. That means the federal government has no real say. With German higher education providers and universities often strapped for cash, partnerships tend to be welcome.
The German Rectors' Conference is reluctant to comment on a possible end to the collaborations. When asked by DW, spokesman Christoph Hilgert emphasized that "the decision of the universities is part of their autonomous action and should be left up to them."
An international problem The Education Ministry has confirmed that plans to deal with Confucius Institutes were also being discussed among European Union member states and in the European Commission.
German Green Party politician Reinhard Bütikofer, who chairs the China delegation in the European Parliament, is clear. "This is no special German problem, this is an international problem," he told DW, referring to similar cases in the US and Sweden where institutes have closed in recent years. However, according to US media reports, some individual facilities have been reestablished under new names.
The issue is also on the political agenda in the United Kingdom. There, Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has repeatedly come under criticism for being too lax when it comes to China's influence. In July 2022, during his bid for the leadership of the Conservative Party, he announced he would close the 30 Confucius Institutes in the UK for "promoting Chinese soft power." In May 2023, he backtracked on that pledge.
When this was met with criticism, Sunak made an issue of China's role in the world in at the end of the G7 summit in May. "They are increasingly authoritarian at home and assertive abroad," he told reporters, speaking of "the systemic challenge that China poses to the world order."
For Bütikofer, the way forward is clear. "These institutes have been able to work in the dark for far too long. It has been obvious for a long time that they are instruments of influence for the Chinese Communist Party. And that is why we need to soberly draw a line," he said.
